Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    39
  • 4 stars
    1
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

5 out of 5 based on 60 ratings.
20 user reviews.
Includes 10 Zillow reviews and 10 Rate My Agent reviews

I can't recommend Cathy Fleischmann enough! She made the entire process of buying a new condo and selling my old one feel seamless and stress-free. From the very beginning, Cathy took the time to really listen to what I wanted in a new home and was incredibly patient as we toured different places until we found the one. She has a great eye for potential and really knows the market, so I felt confident every step of the way. On the selling side, Cathy handled everything with such professionalism. She gave me excellent advice on how to stage my condo, and within no time, we had an offer. Cathy is responsive, knowledgeable, and genuinely cares about her clients. I’m so grateful for all her help and would absolutely work with her again in the future!

Paula Economus
Property

I can't recommend Cathy Fleischmann enough! She made the entire process of buying a new condo and selling my old one feel seamless and stress-free. From the very beginning, Cathy took the time to really listen to what I wanted in a new home and was incredibly patient as we toured different places un... Read More

Paula Economus

It has been a pleasure working with Cathy. She is very knowledgeable, extremely responsive and helps every step of the way in buying a home. If a person is looking for an agent to purchase or sell a home, you could not ask for a better agent. We have enjoyed getting to know her and see her in the future.

Lane Ross
Property

It has been a pleasure working with Cathy. She is very knowledgeable, extremely responsive and helps every step of the way in buying a home. If a person is looking for an agent to purchase or sell a home, you could not ask for a better agent. We have enjoyed getting to know her and see her in the... Read More

Lane Ross

Cathy was a pleasure to work with during our relocation process. She is honest, prompt, and understanding to her clients wants and needs. From our initial tour through the final closing, she was communicative and responsive to all questions and requests. Cathy provided invaluable advice and strategies in order sell our home quickly and over asking price. She has our highest recommendation, and any client would be blessed to have her. Thank you, Cathy, for your professionalism and patience while helping our family relocate out of state.

Maddie Keckeis
Property

Cathy was a pleasure to work with during our relocation process. She is honest, prompt, and understanding to her clients wants and needs. From our initial tour through the final closing, she was communicative and responsive to all questions and requests. Cathy provided invaluable advice and strategi... Read More

Maddie Keckeis

I have worked with Cathy on three separate transactions in the last several years. She is highly communicative and seeks to thoroughly understand her client’s wants, needs, and financial risk appetite. You never have to wonder what is going on with the process, as she is adept at keeping information current in real time. She cares deeply about her client’s satisfaction. I highly recommend.

Amy Becker

Cathy took such great care of me and my husband. We were a first time buyer and didn’t have much knowledge. She is super knowledgeable and explained the process and made each step very clear and simple. We could not ask for a better and more fair agent. Thank you Cathy, we are so happy in our dream home!

Arisa Lomanto
Property

I have worked with Cathy on three separate transactions in the last several years. She is highly communicative and seeks to thoroughly understand her client’s wants, needs, and financial risk appetite. You never have to wonder what is going on with the process, as she is adept at keeping informa... Read More

Amy Becker
Property

Cathy took such great care of me and my husband. We were a first time buyer and didn’t have much knowledge. She is super knowledgeable and explained the process and made each step very clear and simple. We could not ask for a better and more fair agent. Thank you Cathy, we are so happy in our drea... Read More

Arisa Lomanto

As we are not from Columbus, we relied on the expertise of Cathy and her market knowledge to guide us through our purchase. Face time from the location helped determine our interest and assistance with contractors a big plus. Cathy is a true professional.

Cathy held my hand through the whole process. Buying a home in another state is difficult when you can not be on site. That’s when you need someone like Cathy to follow through on every detail for you. And she did a great job!

Janis Bobb
Property

Cathy held my hand through the whole process. Buying a home in another state is difficult when you can not be on site. That’s when you need someone like Cathy to follow through on every detail for you. And she did a great job!

Janis Bobb

Cathy was very responsive to our questions and was a great help to us in securing our property.

Douglas Christopher Compton
Property

Cathy was very responsive to our questions and was a great help to us in securing our property.

Douglas Christopher Compton

Cathy is an outstanding realtor. From start to finish with searching, finding, and building our home she made the experience enjoyable. She always goes above and beyond for us. She went to every appointment with us, got involved and stayed involved through every step of our house buying/ building journey. She truly cares about her clients and the relationship she builds. I would recommend Cathy to anyone. She is by far the best realtor we have ever worked with.

Cathy Fleischmann did a very good job selling our home. We highly recommend her.

Sarah Sargent

Cathy made this experience much easier. I recommend her to anyone buying or selling.

Sherry Distelhorst
Property

Cathy made this experience much easier. I recommend her to anyone buying or selling.

Sherry Distelhorst

I highly recommend Cathy! She is a professional with years of business experience behind her that lend to her success in real estate. She is attentive and responsive, taking time to get to know you to guide you in your property search. I had a challenging situation - a condo in a project that failed and became a majority apartment building. Cathy dealt with a difficult buyer, but her negotiating skills helped me to come away with a deal in time for me to keep my new build. I would definitely choose Cathy again!

I had a great experience with Cathy. She was knowledgeable about the market and how to position to win. She offered great advice, meaningful referrals for execution, and took personal accountability for the process. She made it easy, and I highly recommend.

My husband and I feel extremely grateful to have had Cathy Fleischmann help us find our beautiful home in New Albany! We happened to meet her at an open house she was holding, and were immediately drawn to her kindness and easy going nature. Throughout the search for a new home, she was so communicative, punctual, patient (despite our ever-changing wants/needs), and driven to help us find our perfect home. When our closing became rather complicated, Cathy went above and beyond, and thanks to her tenacity, we finally reached the finish line. Throughout the process, we were impressed with Cathy's impressive knowledge of the market, her honestly, and directness. We truly felt like we had an advocate in our corner who was relentlessly looking out for our best interests. Not only was she our agent, but she also became our friend. What more could you ask for?

Ryan Farah
Property

My husband and I feel extremely grateful to have had Cathy Fleischmann help us find our beautiful home in New Albany! We happened to meet her at an open house she was holding, and were immediately drawn to her kindness and easy going nature. Throughout the search for a new home, she was so communica... Read More

Ryan Farah

My husband and I feel extremely grateful to have had Cathy Fleischmann help us find our beautiful home in New Albany! We happened to meet her at an open house she was holding, and were immediately drawn to her kindness and easy going nature. Throughout the search for a new home, she was so communicative, punctual, patient (despite our ever-changing wants/needs), and driven to help us find our perfect home. When our closing became rather complicated, Cathy went above and beyond, and thanks to her tenacity, we finally reached the finish line. Throughout the process, we were continuously impressed with Cathy's impressive knowledge of the market, her honestly, and directness. We truly felt like we had an advocate in our corner who was relentlessly looking out for our best interests. Not only was she our agent, but she also became our friend. We wholeheartedly recommend Cathy for all real estate needs.

Cathy's attention to detail and ability to seamlessly walk her clients through the process is nothing short of amazing!

Zachary Willard

Cathy was a great realtor who was patient, kind and easy to work with. She was very attentive to my needs as a first time home buyer!

Paula Economus

Cathy is an amazing person to work with. She makes home buying or selling fun and easy! Cathy helped me navigate the real estate market during the Corona Virus pandemic. We were not sure how it would all work out, but using social distancing along with electronic signatures....and we bought a house.

Phyllis Stump

Cathy gets the job done right! Trustworthy, attentive and professional, she went the extra mile to provide me with excellent, timely service on a proactive basis. I thoroughly enjoyed working with Cathy!

Ona Lewis

I would like to thank Cathy Fleischmannfor her incredible patience with me. Finding a home is not easy. We had the pleasure of working with Cathy from Cutler Real estate and she was fantastic! We are forst time homebuyers and cathy was patient and answered every question we had. She was very knowledgeable and honest with her opinions about the homes we viewed. We highly recommend Cathy! Thank you Cathy for all the things you have done for me and my family!!!

Mitra Timsina

Cathy help me with everything i need to know prior to buy property. She run extra miles to help me out to get the house of my choice. I am 100% satisfied with the job she done on behalf of me. I reconmend everyone to work with her. Inspite of some language barier with me and my family she helped us with everything we need. I will be in touch with her forever and will have my friends buy house through her. Thankyou cathy for making me and my family happy.

Mitra Timsina

Cathy was a pleasure to work with! Found a house in a very short time based on her adjusting our searches sometimes weekly! Then when it came time to sell our home again the time she spent to get the photos just perfect the house sold in a day! She is very thorough and persistent! I would highly recommend Cathy for all your real estate needs!

Michele Bridges

My husband and I trust her and admire her ability to get things done. She sold our house in 6 weeks and kept us totally informed. I will continue to recommend her highly. Cathy is the best!

Rosalie P. Ungar

Cathy is an experienced, knowledgeable and resourceful real estate agent. She performed well in all aspects of closing the deal for us. Cathy was highly responsive to all questions put to her. We would indeed highly recommend her to family and friends.

Bobbie Allen and Brad Gillingham

Cathy was flawless in her delivery of excellent service. Made the process streamlined from start to finish, and she is the reason we are in our dream home! Thanks Cathy

Zachary Willard

Rosalie and Ed Ungar

Cathy was flawless in her delivery of excellent service. We wouldn't be in our dream house If it wasn't for her! Cathy sold our condo in 1 day full asking! Thanks again Cathy

Cathy is, hands down, the best realtor I’ve worked with. She is extremely patient, knowledgeable of the area, and honest. She knew exactly what we were looking for and helped us find it. Even after the sale closed, Cathy has been there for us. I highly recommend Cathy!

Jaime Meek

I’m so thankful because I found realtor like Cathy,She is very helpful finally she find a great house for me Thanks cathy whatever u did to me and my family

Cathy Fleischman is an excellent realtor. She is with you from start to finish! She arranged and sold our house while we were in Florida in 2days! We are very thankful for the extra effort she did in making the house showcase ready! We can’t thank her enough!Judge Peter and Marie Economus,

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel